Volume & Issue: Volume 6, Issue 4 - Serial Number 24, Winter 2026 
Number of Articles: 13

Examining the Position of the People and Self-Criticism in the Thought of Religious Intellectuals of the Constitutional Era Based on Their Memoirs

fateme NASROLAHI

Abstract an embrace of modern principles. In Iran, the clash between tradition and modernity gained significant momentum in the late Naser al-Din Shah era, culminating in the establishment of the Constitutional Monarchy during Mozaffar al-Din Shah’s reign. This occurred within a society predominantly comprising uneducated peasants who, facing tyranny, sought refuge primarily within the religious community. Consequently, religious intellectuals were uniquely positioned to enlighten the populace. This research explores the views of the people and the extent of self-criticism among religious intellectuals during the Constitutional Era, as reflected in their memoirs.



The core question is: How did these religious intellectuals, in their memoirs, perceive the populace and its engagement with the Constitutional movement? Furthermore, did they express self-criticism regarding their own endeavors to educate the public on the Constitutional system’s foundational principles? The hypothesis suggests that the depiction of the people in these intellectuals’ writings often underscores public ignorance. Moreover, the level of self-criticism among religious intellectuals varied, influenced by their political affiliations and intellectual perspectives. Employing a descriptive-analytical methodology, and analyzing twelve memoirs, it was found that the presence or absence of a partisan approach among these intellectuals significantly shaped their perceptions of the people and their proposed solutions for solidifying the Constitutional system. Notably, the highest degree of self-criticism was observed among those without explicit partisan ties. A recurring concern for these religious intellectuals was also the widespread ignorance of the people across various political, cultural, and economic spheres.

China's New Foreign Policy in the West Asian Region: A Case Study of the Islamic Republic of Iran and Türkiye

Pages 33-62

ali adami, aboozar nazarian, majidreza momeni, majid abbasi

Abstract The evolution of China's foreign policy in the last decade reflects a transition from an "avoidance of intervention" approach to active and network-oriented activism in the peripheral environment. The West Asian region has become one of the strategic centers of this transformation due to its geopolitical position, energy resources, and transit location. The present study uses the conceptual framework of "neighborhood policy" to explain China's new foreign policy in West Asia and examines Iran and Turkey as two comparative case studies. The main question is how China's policy in this region can be explained in the context of the logic of geoeconomic neighborhood and what factors explain the difference in China's interaction pattern with Iran and Turkey? The findings show that China, within the framework of the Belt and Road megaproject, has adopted a strategy based on deepening economic dependence, diversifying transit routes, and soft balancing against the influence of the United States. In this framework, Iran plays the role of a geopolitical partner in balancing with the West, while Turkey is more defined as a logistical node and connector of Eurasia. The research concludes that China's neighborhood policy is pragmatic, network-oriented, and non-coalitional in nature, and operates based on "comparative geoeconomic balance."

Analysis of the political culture of religious intellectuals after the Islamic Revolution

reza alizadeh, mansour vosoghi, mostafa azkia

Abstract Political culture means structures, values, attitudes, and feelings towards politics and political behavior in society. Given the importance of political culture, the following research uses the Laclau and Mouffe discourse analysis method to study the political culture of Iranian religious intellectuals after the Islamic Revolution. The statistical population includes 20 texts from five religious intellectuals. The findings show that the central signifier of the discourse of these intellectuals was “critique of political power,” which is articulated with floating signifiers including “freedom,” “human rights,” “dialogue and negation of violence,” “civil society,” and “critique of tradition,” which find meaning within the framework of the central signifier. This discourse is a reflection of a participatory political culture that is based on adherence to modern values such as human rights, pluralism, and critical rationality. Religious intellectuals, emphasizing the compatibility of religion and modernity, seek to redefine the relationship between tradition and modernity in the Iranian political space. The results of the research indicate that this discourse has played an effective role in shaping Iran's political and social developments after the revolution and examines the challenges of advancing political development with a critical and reformist perspective.

Studying the Relations between Social Trust and Political Participation: A Comparative Analysis of the Iranian Presidential Elections in 2017, 2021, and 2024

Nabi Azadi, Ghorbanali Ghorbanzadeh Savar

Abstract The relations between social trust and political participation is one of the fundamental topics in political sociology. Research indicates that in societies with high levels of social trust also exhibit higher rate of political participation. Social capital is playing a key role in this relationship through the component of trust. Social trust not only facilitates individual interactions but also strengthens social cohesion, trust in institutions, and support for the political system. Onthe contrary, the lack of social trust reduces political participation and collective action. The main question is whether a decline in social trust, particularly trust in political institutions, has had a meaningful correlation with declining political participation in the last three presidential elections. The research findings demonstrate a direct and positive correlation between social trust and political participation; in other words, the level of political participation is a function of citizens’ trust in the political system. To analyze this nexus, political participation in the last Iranian presidential elections of 2017, 2021, and 2024 was examined using Robert Putnam’s and Michael Woolcock’s social capital theories. Results revealed that besides the correlation between social trust and political participation, the imbalance in attention to various types of social capital—bonding, bridging, and linking-are among the most important factors contributing to the decline in social trust. This imbalance has led to decreased citizens’ trust in the system and subsequently reduced their political participation. Such a relationship produces a vicious cycle of declining trust, reduced participation, weakened legitimacy, intensifying crises, and further erosion of trust.

Framing Contestation in Iran’s Hijab Policy: From the Coloniality of Power to the Third Model of Muslim Woman

Hakimeh Saghaye-Biria

Abstract This article, using a policy framing analysis, examines the issue of hijab in Iran as a case of frame contestation, in which competing meanings of womanhood, freedom, agency, and dignity are constructed and negotiated. The theoretical foundation is based on the concept of coloniality of power, revealing how Reza Shah’s forced unveiling policy established a colonial frame of the “modern woman,” where visibility became a marker of femininity and a symbol of civilizational progress. In its contemporary form, global cultural and media powers have continued to deploy this colonial frame to redefine Iranian womanhood. Drawing on recent findings in psychology and gender studies, the paper introduces de-objectification as a counter-frame to this visibility-based logic. From this perspective, objectification is not merely an individual or moral issue but a structural social process reproduced through cultural, economic, and media institutions. Its psychological and social harms – ranging from anxiety and depression to violence and family disintegration – underscore the need for systemic transformation toward a cultural order grounded in dignity, agency, and moral integrity. Finally, inspired by Ayatollah Khamenei’s notion of the “Third Model of Muslim Woman,” the paper conceptualizes de-objectification as a policy framework for reconstructing womanhood in terms of dignity and agency. It concludes that the resolution of Iran’s hijab controversy requires a structural shift from the colonial frame of freedom as visibility toward a national and moral policy of de-objectification, enabling social convergence and civilizational renewal.

Examining the changing positions of the Supreme Leader in foreign policy; presenting a theoretical model regarding the differences in foundations, principles, and behaviors

morteza hadadi, hamid saeedijavadi, mohammad laelalizadeh

Abstract It is important to understand the positions of leadership in foreign policy from different perspectives. In the first stage, conflicting positions can be perceived in different periods, and in the absence of a theoretical basis for describing and analyzing the positions of the leadership, any evaluation of positions is reduced to a kind of formal conflict and superficial perception. With the aim of getting rid of these conflicts and perceptions, an attempt has been made to provide a theoretical model based on the separation of foundations from principles and behaviors, by using a descriptive-analytical method and by using library resources and analyzing leadership positions and speeches within the framework of a theoretical model, in order to provide a basis for simultaneously explaining fixed foundations and interpretable principles and variable, flexible, appropriate, and tactical behaviors.

The findings indicate that changing positions in foreign policy based on the theoretical model presented, without changing the principles and worldview of leadership, is affected by the interpretation of principles and changing behaviors according to domestic requirements and the international system and changing international conditions.

aaa

hadis bagherinia, farzaneh dashti, a arasteh

Abstract The first Pahlavi period (1304-1320 AH) is considered one of the most challenging and turbulent periods in the contemporary history of Iran. During this period, extensive political, social, and cultural developments took place in the country, the consequences of which can still be seen today. One of the most important of these developments was the crisis of national identity and historical fragility that Iranian society was struggling with. Therefore, the aim of the present research is to analyze the crisis of national identity and historical fragility in the first Pahlavi period. Therefore, the main question of the research is: "What are the factors affecting the crisis of national identity and historical fragility in the first Pahlavi period?" In this regard, the present research uses a qualitative descriptive-analytical method to analyze the crisis of national identity and historical fragility in the Reza Khan period. The dominant approach in this article is to use the theory of the crisis of national identity. The data was collected using a library-documentary method using file-taking from documents, books, articles, etc. The research findings indicate that the factors affecting the national identity crisis and the historical fragility of the first Pahlavi period, according to the theory of identity crises, can be said to be multiple factors such as; Western culture, sanctions and economic influences, cultural and artistic influences, political influences, the ideological nature of national identity and its exploitation by political regimes played a role in the emergence and deepening of the identity.

The Role of the Culture of Self-Sacrifice and Martyrdom in the Dynamism and Development of Islamic Society

soheila lashkari, Habibollah Golmohammadi Golmohammadi

Abstract The culture of self-sacrifice and martyrdom, as a vital foundation of religious, national, and human identity, plays an irreplaceable role in the formation, endurance, and advancement of societies. Rooted in values such as devotion, altruism, prioritizing collective interests, and sacrificing one’s life for noble ideals, this culture proves essential not only during crises such as wars and revolutions but also in sustaining long-term social, cultural, and scientific development. In Islamic teachings, self-sacrifice and martyrdom hold an exalted position and are repeatedly emphasized in the Holy Qur’an. Religious and intellectual leaders, particularly the Supreme Leader, have underscored the need to institutionalize this culture among all segments of society, especially the youth and academic communities.



This paper explores the multifaceted dimensions of the culture of self-sacrifice and martyrdom, focusing on the pivotal role of the humanities in interpreting, promoting, and deepening this culture. It examines religious, social, and cultural perspectives while highlighting the interdisciplinary contributions of philosophy, sociology, history, psychology, literature, and the arts in shaping related concepts. Moreover, the study investigates challenges faced by universities in fostering this culture through the humanities and proposes strategies such as strengthening interdisciplinary education, encouraging applied research, and employing cultural and media initiatives to reinforce the values of sacrifice and devotion.



The findings suggest that revitalizing this culture strengthens national unity, enhances social responsibility, and increases social capital—thereby contributing to sustainable development and moral resilience within society

The Concepts of Tamlikiyyah and Velayatiyyah Monarchies in the Political Thought of Ayatollah Naini

Mohammad Jalilfar, MohammadKazem Kaveh Pishghadam

Abstract Abstract

This study examines the concepts of Tamlikiyyah (proprietary monarchy) and Velayatiyyah (mandated/guardianship monarchy) through a descriptive library method from the perspective of the prominent religious jurist and political scholar, Ayatollah Naini. The aim is to examine and compare these two forms of monarchy as articulated by Allameh Naini, an influential thinker in political and social matters, and to explain his views during the political conflicts between proponents and opponents of the Iranian Constitutional Movement in the face of authoritarian rule. According to Naini, the stability of the global order and human life is inherently tied to governance and politics. He analyzes two distinct forms of monarchy: Tamlikiyyah, which he criticizes as a system of enslavement and subjugation, and Velayatiyyah, which he praises for its emphasis on public participation and liberty. Naini considers Tamlikiyyah monarchy to be founded on absolute domination and inequality, where the sovereign exercises unrestricted ownership over the country, the state fully submits to the monarch, and all governing power is concentrated in the ruler's hands. In contrast, Velayatiyyah monarchy is rooted in freedom and equality. In this form of governance, the ruler’s authority is limited to serving the public interest, and the liberation of the nation from servitude to the sovereign is paramount. Naini highlights that the governance in a Velayatiyyah system aligns with Islamic principles and is superior to despotism. Through a detailed examination of these two forms, the study concludes that Ayatollah Naini regarded Velayatiyyah monarchy as an ideal form of Islamic governance.

Identifying the Dimensions of an Entrepreneurship Education Model for Secondary School Students in Hormozgan Province, Iran

esam taheri, mehdi bagheri, Kolsum Nami

Abstract This study aimed to identify the dimensions of a model for entrepreneurship education among secondary school students in Hormozgan Province, Iran. The research was exploratory in purpose and employed a qualitative approach. In the qualitative phase, the study population consisted of educational experts and specialists from the Hormozgan Province Department of Education. Using purposive sampling, ten participants were selected for in-depth interviews. In the quantitative phase, in order to evaluate and fit the model based on the criteria extracted from the qualitative findings, the perspectives of all secondary school teachers and school principals in Hormozgan Province were used. Data collection in the qualitative phase was conducted through semi-structured interviews. The interview data were analyzed and coded using MAXQDA software. The results of initial coding showed that 50 primary codes were extracted from 242 meaningful segments of the interviews. Furthermore, axial coding results indicated that these 50 primary codes were categorized into eight main dimensions: economic outcomes related to student entrepreneurship, educational factors, organizational factors, political and governmental factors, individual factors, financial factors, environmental factors, and individual benefits associated with student entrepreneurship.

نگاهی جامعه‌شناختی به معقوله معماری الگوی پیشرفت اسلامی ایرانی

mahdi salehi, صالحی salehi

Abstract هدف: این پژوهش با هدف واکاوی و تبیین نقش محوری معماری در تحقق اهداف و آرمان‌های الگوی پیشرفت اسلامی ایرانی، رویکردی جامعه‌شناختی را در پیش گرفته است. هدف اصلی، شناسایی شکاف میان واقعیت‌های کالبدی معماری معاصر و الزامات نظری الگوی مذکور و ارائه چارچوبی برای همسوسازی طراحی فضایی با مؤلفه‌های هویتی و ارزشی است.

روش‌شناسی: پژوهش حاضر با اتکا به روشی توصیفی-تحلیلی و با استفاده از مطالعات کتابخانه‌ای و اسنادی، به تحلیل مبانی نظری الگوی پیشرفت، مفاهیم جامعه‌شناسی فضا و اصول بنیادین معماری اسلامی-ایرانی می‌پردازد. تأکید اصلی بر این فرضیه استوار است که معماری نه یک خروجی صرف، بلکه یک بستر اجتماعی است که می‌تواند به بازتولید یا انهدام ساختارهای مطلوب تمدنی کمک کند.

یافته‌ها: نتایج نشان می‌دهد که معماری معاصر ایران، در غیاب یک تئوری منسجم مبتنی بر الگوی پیشرفت، دچار تقلیل‌گرایی کارکردی و زیبایی‌شناختی شده است. این رویکرد، منجر به ایجاد فضاهایی گردیده که در تضاد با مفاهیمی چون “تعالی”، “عدالت اجتماعی” و “هویت اصیل” قرار می‌گیرند. یافته‌ها بر لزوم توجه به ابعاد اجتماعی-فرهنگی و معنوی در کنار ابعاد فنی و کالبدی تأکید دارند؛ به‌گونه‌ای که هر عنصر معماری، حامل معنایی همسو با ارزش‌های اسلامی-ایرانی باشد.

دستیابی به الگوی پیشرفت اسلامی ایرانی مستلزم یک انقلاب نرم در نگرش به معماری است. این تحول، تنها از طریق نهادینه کردن رویکرد جامعه‌شناختی در فرایند طراحی و ساخت میسر خواهد بود تا معماری به جای تقلید از مدل‌های وارداتی، به مثابه یک عامل فعال در تحقق آرمان‌های تمدنی عمل نموده و بستر مناسبی برای زیست باکیفیت (مادی و معنوی) فراهم آورد.

A Historical and Analytical Study of the Role of Educators and Academics in Arak in the Developments Leading to the Victory of the Islamic Revolution (1971–1979)

Ali Zareei, Marzieh Radbakhsh

Abstract Contrary to the common belief in certain segments of public opinion that the city of Arak played only a marginal role in the course of the Islamic Revolution, examination of existing documents and narratives shows that this city—like many others in Iran—had a noteworthy presence in the protests and activities preceding 1979. In particular, two groups—educators and academics—each, by making use of their professional capacities and social networks, helped shape part of the political, cultural, and social developments of this period.



Adopting a historical‑analytical approach and drawing on the theoretical frameworks of resource mobilization and social capital, this study examines the role of these two groups between 1971 and 1979. Data were collected and analyzed through archival documents (especially SAVAK reports), interviews with revolutionary activists, and library sources.



Findings indicate that educators, using schools as a platform, were active in organizing gatherings, nationwide strikes, and awareness‑raising cultural programs such as protest theater. Meanwhile, academics—including faculty members and students of the Arak Higher School of Sciences—played a facilitative and organizing role for the youth by forming Islamic associations, holding book and photo exhibitions, reproducing and distributing leaflets, and turning the university into a starting point for citywide demonstrations.



Cooperation and synergy between these two groups, though not unparalleled on the national level, created a local linkage between educational protest movements and the public sphere of the city, thereby contributing, in its own measure, to the process that culminated in the victory of the Islamic Revolution.

A Strategic Model of Cultural Defense Against Cognitive Warfare: A Qur’an-Based Approach

Ahmad Parna, Seyyed Abdolrasoul Hosseinizadeh, Mehdi Bakooei

Abstract In the contemporary security ecosystem, the paradigm of conflict has shifted from hard military confrontation to "Cognitive Warfare" and "Cultural Invasion," where conquering the cognitive apparatus and transforming national-religious identity replaces territorial conquest. This research aims to explicate the Islamic defense doctrine by analyzing Quranic strategies to counter soft infiltration and immunize society against information disorders. Adopting a descriptive-analytical approach and utilizing the theoretical frameworks of "Soft Power" and "Passive Defense," this study aligns revealed teachings with modern theories of communication science and political psychology. The findings indicate that the Holy Quran offers a "systematic and multi-layered" defense system based on eight fundamental pillars: 1) Enhancing "Insight (Basira) and Critical Thinking" to distinguish truth from falsehood; 2) Reconstructing "Cultural Identity" based on mutual recognition; 3) Strengthening the "Family Institution" as a center of tranquility; 4) "Producing High-Quality Content" based on knowledge; 5) Developing vibrant "Cultural Programs"; 6) Utilizing "Media Power" for social monitoring; 7) "Analytical Vigilance" against imported content; and 8) Establishing "International Coalitions" based on piety. The conclusion suggests that implementing these strategies transitions society from passivity to "Smart Resistance," guaranteeing cognitive resilience and cultural independence in the era of globalization.